Monday, 17 February 2020

BBC increasingly guilty of repeating a lot of hot air



The recent BBC investigation Meat: A Threat to our Planet? has caused quite a storm.
For many farmers, much of the issue they had with the programme was that they filmed the majority of it in America, where standards of welfare are substantially below those that British farmers adhere to. But the BBC implied throughout much of the programme that  what was been said was equally applicable to any livestock farmer - even here in the UK. 
Some things they stated were just plain wrong. Below is just one such example.
The BBC said: “Over the course of a year, the burps from a single extra cow heat the planet as much as burning around 600 litres of petrol. Together with all other livestock, the meat industry now produces more greenhouse gases than the running of all our transport”.
Fact: As far as the UK is concerned, this claim is completely erroneous. Figures from the Committee on Climate Change show that UK agriculture as a whole accounts for 10% of greenhouse gas emissions, compared with 24% for energy supplies and 27% for transport. Furthermore, of farming’s 10% contribution, just 4.5% is from livestock.
When I was growing up, everyone had huge respect for the BBC, especially the standards that their journalists upheld. Perhaps we were just being naive? 
Nowadays however, I feel that there is an underlying attitude of "don't let the odd miss-truth get in the way of creating a damn good, headline grabbing story". 
That is a great shame. 


Wednesday, 12 February 2020

What's that bird?


I held a small bird ID day for the Chalke Valley Farmers Cluster in Wiltshire the other day. A reasonably sunny, dry day, was great for spotting birds, but also meant that a number of folk could not attend as they were making the most of this pleasant gap in the weather, so were collectively sitting on tractors - drilling!

Budding ornithologists, including host farmer (second from left) Ben Jeans
We did a circular walk and found good numbers of birds including lots of Corn bunting, Yellowhammer, Reed bunting, Chaffinch and Linnet. Not surprising because Ben Jeans, the host farmer, grows crops for feeding birds over-winter and supplements these crops with extra mixed seeds spread along track-sides and field margins.

One field of over-wintering stubble with a good regrowth of barley volunteers (the word "volunteers" is used by farmers to indicate that plants were not deliberately sown, but have grown from spilt seed whilst harvesting) was full of Meadow pipits and above, high in the sky, Skylarks sang. In the distance Ravens "cronked" and Buzzards "mewed".

Trying to identify birds, especially at some distance is not easy - especially as so many of them classically look like "LBJs" - little brown jobs! However, we discussed how the "Jizz" of the bird can help you to home in on its identity. Jizz is a birders term for the little things that a particular bird does - flicking its tail, sitting very upright or a very bouncy flight - that sort of thing. Jotting these things down with the help of a pencil and notepad, will help you potentially find your bird when back in the house with a cup of coffee and a bird book!

One bird that everyone cracked was the Song thrush. This bird has a habit of repeating phrases when singing. It picks a few notes and repeats them three or four times, followed by a small gap, and then into a different phrase, which once again it will repeat.

It was great to hear a real cacophony of House sparrows when we returned to the farm - once common, it is now a bird in decline - but not on this farm!

Thanks must go to Simon Smart, who is the facilitator of this farmers group and the organiser of their events and of course to Ben, a farmer who is acutely aware of his responsibilities as the manager of "his" little bit of England - growing food and looking after the environment - a job that he does so well. 


Tuesday, 11 February 2020

Farmer sheds light on his carbon footprint


Did you know that any given moment in time, there are on average 9,728 commercial planes in the air, carrying 1,270,406 passengers? In 2019, 4.5 billion passengers were carried by commercial airlines. Aviation is responsible for 12% of carbon emissions worldwide, whilst road transport is responsible for a whacking 74%. 
  
Why do I mention this?

Well George Hosier, a farming friend of mine, recently travelled to Australia on an Airbus A380 to visit some relatives. These massive planes carry approximately 500 passengers and use 330,000 litres of fuel for a one-way flight to Melbourne. 

George worked out that this is over 9 years’ worth of fuel use on his farm, during which time he produced enough wheat for 23 million loaves of bread, barley for 152 million pints of beer, peas for 700,000 cans of mushy peas and 500 cattle for prime, grass fed beef. 

George went on to say “Now I am not for one second saying that farming is perfect or that no one should travel in aeroplanes, but within the farming industry there is a feeling that we are being singled out as the bad guys in the whole climate change debate, when actually we all need to look at our personal carbon footprint and all make little changes to reduce our consumption of fossil fuels.

For instance, we could reduce travel (or swap the car for the train where possible), reduce food waste (as a nation we throw away 1/3 of the food purchased), buy local to cut down food miles, reuse/repair more and recycle more. If we all do a little it will start to add up!”

I would also add that George has put about 5 miles of new hedgerows in, to encourage wildlife. He also grows “wild bird seed mixes” – non-harvested crops grown specifically for feeding wild birds’ over-winter. He also supplementary feeds birds too, by scattering mixed seeds along tracks and field edges from January until April as food is in short supply at this time of year.

George is also an advocate of “no-till” farming. He basically does not cultivate his arable land, but instead drills crops straight into the ground. This obviously saves fuel (pulling a plough through the ground is hard work for the tractor which consumes lots of diesel) and because the soil is not disturbed, earthworm numbers rocket. They help to break down organic matter, aerate the soil and provide lots of extra food for birds and mammals.

Soil is also a great sequester of carbon, especially if it is not cultivated. Also, because the stubble from the previous crop is left on the surface, rather than been buried by the plough, birds find lots of food that would otherwise have been hidden underground. 
  
In November 2011 George put PV solar panels on two separate barns at either end of the farm, which provides a total of 54kw/h and helps to reduce his carbon footprint and reduce the electricity costs to his business.

Now, George is a great example of the way that farmers can look to improve how they farm more environmentally. But do not think that he is in a minority in the way he thinks and acts. There has been a big sea change in the way many farmers are now farming, with a keen eye on how to improve the quality of their soils, water and the environment in general.

At the Oxford Farming Conference in January 2019, the excellent National Farmers Union president Minette Batters announced the NFU’s ambition to achieve net zero for agriculture by 2040. With farmers such as George leading the way, I think that this is perfectly achievable.

Farming currently creates around 10% of the UK’s greenhouse emissions. But as George says, “there is a feeling that we are being singled out as the bad guys in the whole Climate Change Debate”.

I would say, yes, there is much work to be done, but I think that farmers fully realise this and are grasping the nettle with both hands. Plus, don’t forget that in the meantime they are growing the food to sustain us all – something that a well-fed, affluent population sometimes seem to forget. So maybe a little less farmer bashing and a bit more encouragement might be the order of the day looking forward?


Wednesday, 29 January 2020

Perhaps the Government can't see the wood for the trees!


Trees, indeed virtually all plants, play an important role in the removal of carbon dioxide from the atmosphere. Through the biochemical process of photosynthesis, carbon dioxide is taken in by trees and stored as carbon in the trunk, branches, leaves and roots.

The Committee on Climate Change’s own analysis outlines that 32,000 hectares of net woodland increase is required annually, for the next 30 years. This would move the UK from 13% to 17% woodland cover and help to achieve the legally binding target of net zero carbon emissions by 2050. This equates to a million new hectares of woodland cover - some 1.5 billion trees.

The increase in planting is going to have to be huge - for the past 25 years no more than 10,000 hectares of new woodland has been planted in any one year across the UK. 

Plenty of organisations have been quick to shout about their plans. For instance, the National Trust wants to create 18,000 hectares (44,478 acres) of new woodland across England, Wales and Northern Ireland by 2030, planting some 20 million trees.

All of this might well be fine if it is all properly thought through.

We live on a relatively small piece of land here in the UK and our growing population is already placing huge pressures on the land we have available. If tree planting is targeted at places where the trees will not only help with carbon sequestration, but also help to prevent soil erosion and potential flooding, (by holding back water), create new habitat for wildlife, while also giving places for people to get some fresh air - then great!

But will this be the case or does the clamour for planting many more trees, simply result in them being plonked anywhere? If that is the case, does it actually matter?

Well yes, I think it does.

If you have an “open” river flood plain that is lucky enough to still have declining breeding species such as Curlew, Lapwing, Redshank and Snipe nesting there, then tree planting would quickly see these species move away. They hate trees, because that is where avian predators sit and watch their ever move.

Parts of the country that have wide open vistas with few trees attract species that favour that sort of landscape. This is why an area such as the Salisbury plain is potentially good for Corn bunting, Grey partridge, Stone curlew and Quail. Once again tree planting would, over time, move these species away.

Also, what about feeding ourselves? Do we really want to plant trees on good agricultural land? Surely, we want to try to become more self-sufficient rather than importing food from around the world with the corresponding carbon footprint that follows such a scenario.

Can’t we also be a bit more imaginative? Presently, we densely plant half a dozen tree species across the country, in a forestry style designed for timber production. (By the way – you need to do this to get the grant!)

A new, grant aided, densely planted small woodland in rows - in my view unimaginative, boring and not that great for wildlife

Many of the new tree planting areas, especially if they are on steep slopes, wet ground or are relatively small, oddly shaped woods, will never be realistically used for timber production. So why these ridiculous planting guidelines that must be followed?  Indeed, why trees at all – what about shrubs?

Give me a couple of hectares (5 acres) and let me plant it up with species such as Hawthorn, Buckthorn, Guelder rose, Wild privet, Dogwood, Spindle, Hazel, Holly and maybe some Crab apple. I would leave around 10 to 20% of the area un-planted, to create open glades within the shrubbery, which could be planted with native wild flowers. 

Within 5 years this would be the most wonderful wildlife haven, providing pollen and nectar and of course berries, fruit and nuts come the winter. A very different scenario from the 5 year old wood made up solely of trees, which planted so closely together, would be offering little to wildlife at this stage. Shrubs grow much faster than trees and are also powerful carbon sequestration systems in their own right!

Plus, what about Agro-forestry, where a farmer might plant only 100 trees a hectare (instead of well over a 1000 per hectare in a forestry plan) and continue to graze the pasture under the trees with livestock? Don’t forget that permanent pasture is also a great sequester of carbon!

The French Ministry of Agriculture has a target of ‘50% of farmers using Agro-forestry by 2025’. 

Sheep grazing amongst newly planted trees - Agro-forestry

The UK needs to increase its woodland cover, but we are also losing many trees through Ash die-back disease. It is reckoned that we may well lose over 95% of Ash trees, one of our most common trees in the landscape.

It is worth noting that with current tree planting pledges, the UK’s existing tree nurseries will quickly run out of native sourced and grown trees, so there is a supply chain issue. The ash die-back fungus was almost certainly introduced through imported sapling trees for planting in the UK. 

So, the Government needs to do much, much more than just announce impressive sounding tree planting targets. It needs to overhaul its grant system so as to much better fund Agroforestry and grant aid the planting of shrubs – something I have banged on about for what seems like a life time!

They also need to give better guidance as to the best places to plant new woodland and importantly, where might not be the best place. Finally, they need to fund more tree and shrub nurseries in this country and meanwhile, put in more robust controls over imported saplings, so that we do not introduce further diseases.     



Tuesday, 21 January 2020

Despite it being mid-winter, there is still lots to look out for!

Nature often gets ready for spring way before spring arrives. Walking in my local wood yesterday reminded me of this. 

Yew trees are dioecious, meaning that male and female flowers grow on separate trees. The picture below, which I took on my walk, shows a male tree covered in loads of little round flower buds, waiting to burst open in the next few weeks and release masses of pollen into the air. Meanwhile the female flowers on nearby trees will be waiting to intercept some of this pollen as it floats through the air. These will develop over the summer months until eventually they will produce the bright red fruits that we all know.

Also in the centre of the picture you can see the clustered leaf formation of the Yew gall midge (Taxomyia taxi), often known as the Yew artichoke gall - for obvious reasons! I reckon this gall is actually quite common, but suspect it is often overlooked as it so easily passes off as a new growth shoot. 

Inside the gall will be the little orange coloured larvae that can mature after one year, but will very often stay put for two years, hatching eventually in July as an adult flying midge.

So check out your nearby Yew trees - there is always something happening in every month of the year.



A Yew artichoke gall (centre) surrounded by male flowers on a Yew tree, waiting to open in a month or so, in order to release loads of pollen 

Thursday, 16 January 2020

Listening fungi - you must be joking!

Jew's ear fungus


A couple of weeks ago, I came across some small, rather shrivelled up fungi in my local wood. I assumed that they were probably Auricularia auricula-judae, commonly called Jew's ear, Jelly ear or Wood ear fungus, as they can quite often resemble an ear!

I know that these fungi can dry out completely or freeze solid, becoming shrivelled, dry and brittle. However, when the rain returns, they can reabsorb water and “flesh out” once again. So yesterday following a very wet few days, I returned to where I had found them and was rewarded with some spectacular fungi!

The term “Jew’s ear” might seem a rather peculiar name, but it certainly was not intended to be anti-Semitic. It is a reference to the fact that Judas Iscariot is believed to have hanged himself from an Elder tree, because of the shame he felt after betraying Jesus to his executioners. This fungus is most often found (but not exclusively) growing on Elder and it is thought that the ears that emerge are visible reminders of Judas’ tormented spirit.  

The flesh of the ear is purple-brown in colour and has quite a gelatinous feel to it when touched. Although I have never tried them, they are apparently quite good to eat and are popular in some eastern countries.

It just shows that even in the middle of winter, there is plenty to find in the countryside if you keep your eyes, and dare I say it “ears” open too!